Cracked Heat Exchanger: Symptoms and How It's Confirmed
Signs of a cracked furnace heat exchanger, how a technician confirms it with a camera and CO readings, what to do after a red tag, and repair vs replace.
Read the guide
Furnace repair in Champlin's 1975–2000 split-entries and ramblers starts with a $79 trip charge, waived when you approve the repair. Many of those furnaces are 80% models venting into the chimney. Hot-surface igniters, flame sensors and inducer motors are the usual failures on those furnaces.
Champlin's houses are mostly split-entries, ramblers and two-stories from about 1975 to 2000, and many are on their second furnace, frequently an 80% model vented through a metal flue or the chimney. Those furnaces fail in predictable ways. Hot surface igniters crack after enough cycles, flame sensors foul, inducer motors get noisy, and the limit or rollout switch trips when a filter plugs. We watch the startup sequence, find the step where it stops, and test that part with a meter.
Houses still running an original 1970s or 80s furnace get extra attention. At that age the heat exchanger is the concern, so we inspect it and check for carbon monoxide around the furnace and flue. If we find a crack, the furnace gets shut off and red-tagged, and you get a written replacement price to go with it. Split-entries put the furnace in the lower level, usually with decent room to work.
Updated October 27, 2026
National averages (HomeGuide, 2026), not our prices: a flame sensor $80–$250, a pressure switch $150–$400, a limit switch $100–$375. More in the furnace repair cost guide.
Symptom guides: Won't ignite · Short cycling · Blinking light codes · Pressure switch trips · Signs your furnace needs a technician
It depends on the failure. An igniter, flame sensor or draft inducer on a 20-year-old 80% furnace is a reasonable repair, and we'll price it in writing. A cracked heat exchanger, or a gas valve and a control board failing in the same winter, tips it toward replacement. If you do replace, remember that moving to a 96% furnace changes the venting and can leave the water heater alone in the chimney.
They affect each other. If the shared flue or chimney is partly blocked, or the vent connector has come loose, flue gas can spill back at the water heater's draft hood. Signs are soot or rust on top of the water heater, melted plastic on its fittings, or a CO alarm. In Champlin's 80% furnace homes this shared flue is common, so draft should be tested at both appliances with both running.
Signs of a cracked furnace heat exchanger, how a technician confirms it with a camera and CO readings, what to do after a red tag, and repair vs replace.
Read the guideFurnace out on a cold Minnesota night? The checks to make in order, reading the blink code, keeping pipes safe while you wait, and when to call 612-429-3465.
Read the guideFurnace quit in a cold snap? Learn how to clear an iced PVC vent safely and stop it from recurring. If it won't stay lit, call 612-429-3465.
Read the guideHeat out? AC quit? Call or send a request.