96% vs 98% AFUE Furnace: Worth the Upgrade in Minnesota?
A 98% AFUE furnace saves only about 2% more gas than a 96% model. Our condensing furnaces run $6,500–$9,500 installed. See what the extra buys.
Read the guide
We replace furnaces in Forest Lake for $4,500–$9,500 installed, with a written flat-rate quote sized by Manual J. If your road is due to get Xcel Energy gas, we can install a propane furnace that converts later with the manufacturer's kit.
Furnace replacement in Forest Lake depends on where the house sits. In town and the newer subdivisions, it's a basement job on Xcel Energy gas: Manual J sizing, PVC venting through the rim joist, a condensate drain and a permit.
Lake homes are harder. A cabin winterized piece by piece may have a small furnace in a crawlspace, ducts that never reached the additions and a lot of heat loss through old walls, so the load calculation has to cover the house as it stands now. In a crawlspace, the new furnace and its condensate line need protection from freezing, and the PVC terminations need to clear the snow. On propane acreage, a 96% furnace saves more fuel dollars per season than it would on natural gas, since propane usually costs more per unit of heat.
Updated November 10, 2026
By efficiency: 80% AFUE roughly $4,500–$6,000; 96–98% AFUE roughly $6,500–$9,500. See the furnace replacement cost guide.
For a home moving off propane, look at Xcel's Make the Switch to Natural Gas program along with its heating equipment rebates for high-efficiency gas furnaces. Ask us which rebates apply when we quote. Rebate programs change every year, so check the utility's current terms before you buy.
Our guides: Xcel and CenterPoint rebates, heat pump rebates.
We'd avoid it. A Minnesota attic drops well below freezing, which puts the condensate line of a 96% furnace at risk and loses heat through any duct leak, and service access is poor. A closet, a utility room or an insulated crawlspace is usually a better home for the furnace, and in a small cabin a ductless heat pump can skip the furnace question entirely. We look at the floor plan before recommending a spot.
It changes the controls more than the furnace. A Wi-Fi thermostat that alerts you to low indoor temperatures, or a separate freeze alarm, is worth more in an empty house than a higher efficiency tier. A two-stage furnace is still a good fit, and the condensate path should stay in heated space so it can't freeze while nobody's there. Set a minimum temperature that protects the plumbing, and have the furnace checked before you leave in fall.
Signs your furnace needs replacing
A 98% AFUE furnace saves only about 2% more gas than a 96% model. Our condensing furnaces run $6,500–$9,500 installed. See what the extra buys.
Read the guideTrane or Carrier furnace? How the lineups match up, warranty registration windows, quote checks and Minnesota install costs of $4,500–$9,500.
Read the guideMost furnace replacements take one day; venting, a chimney liner, gas line or duct work can add a second. Ours run $4,500–$9,500 installed. Call 612-429-3465.
Read the guideHeat out? AC quit? Call or send a request.